A Beginner’s Guide to the Florida Appellate Process

Image courtesy of Aaron Burden / Unsplash

An Overview of Appellate Review, Procedures, and Court Structure in Florida

The Florida appellate process plays a distinct role within the state’s judicial system. Unlike trial courts, which resolve disputes by evaluating evidence and testimony, appellate courts focus on reviewing legal decisions made by lower courts. For individuals unfamiliar with appeals, the process can seem complex and highly procedural. 

By breaking the process down into distinct segments, it can be easier to understand. This educational overview will explain how the Florida appellate system works, what to expect at each stage, and the legal principles that govern appellate review.

Understanding the Purpose of an Appeal

An appeal is not a second trial. Instead, it is a formal request for a higher court to review whether a legal error occurred during a lower court proceeding. Florida appellate courts generally do not hear new evidence or reconsider factual determinations made by a judge or jury. Their role is limited to reviewing the legal rulings applied to the existing record.

Appeals serve an important function by promoting consistency in the interpretation of Florida law and ensuring that trial courts apply legal standards correctly.

Image courtesy of Wesley Tingey / Unsplash

Florida’s Court Structure Explained

Florida’s judicial system is divided into trial courts and appellate courts.

Trial courts are where cases begin, evidence is presented, and factual determinations are made. They include:

• County courts

• Circuit courts

Most appeals from trial courts are heard by one of Florida’s District Courts of Appeal. The Florida Supreme Court primarily reviews cases involving significant constitutional questions, conflicts between appellate decisions, or issues of statewide importance, often on a discretionary basis.

Which Decisions Can Be Appealed

Not every court ruling may be appealed immediately. In Florida, appellate jurisdiction generally depends on the type of order issued.

Final orders, which resolve all issues in a case, are typically appealable as a matter of right. Non-final orders may only be appealed if they fall within specific categories authorized by Florida appellate rules. Administrative agency decisions may also be subject to appellate review under separate procedures.

Additionally, appellate courts usually only consider issues that were properly raised and preserved during the trial court proceedings.

How an Appeal Begins

The appellate process formally begins with the filing of a notice of appeal. This document notifies the court and the opposing party that appellate review is being sought. Florida appellate rules impose strict deadlines for filing a notice of appeal, and failure to meet those deadlines can affect appellate jurisdiction.

After the notice is filed, the record on appeal is prepared. The record typically includes pleadings, orders, transcripts, and other materials from the trial court that are relevant to the issues being reviewed.

Image courtesy of Scott Graham / Unsplash

The Role of Written Briefs

Written briefs are the foundation of most Florida appeals. These documents explain the legal arguments and cite relevant statutes, rules, and case law.

The briefing process generally includes:

• An initial brief filed by the appellant

• An answer brief filed by the appellee

• A reply brief addressing arguments raised in the answer brief

A central component of appellate briefing is the standard of review. This determines how closely the appellate court examines the lower court’s decision. Some rulings receive de novo review, while others are reviewed for abuse of discretion or competent substantial evidence.

Oral Argument in Appellate Courts

In some cases, appellate courts allow oral argument. Oral argument is not guaranteed and is often granted only when the court believes discussion may assist in resolving the legal issues.

During oral argument, attorneys present their positions and answer questions from the appellate judges. No witnesses testify, and no new evidence is introduced. Many appeals are decided solely on the written briefs without oral argument.

Appellate Decisions and Their Meaning

After reviewing the briefs and, if applicable, oral argument, the appellate court issues a decision. Decisions may take several forms.

Some cases result in a written opinion explaining the court’s reasoning. Others may be resolved through a per curiam affirmance, which upholds the lower court’s ruling without a written explanation.

Possible outcomes include affirmance, reversal, or remand. A remand sends the case back to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with the appellate decision.

Options After an Appellate Decision

In limited circumstances, parties may seek further review after an appellate decision. Options may include motions for rehearing, clarification, or certification of a question to the Florida Supreme Court.

The Florida Supreme Court has discretionary jurisdiction in many cases, meaning it selects which cases to review based on specific legal criteria. Not all appellate decisions are eligible for further review.

How Long Appeals Typically Take

Appeals often take longer than trial court proceedings. The timeline depends on several factors, including the complexity of the issues, the size of the record, and the court’s docket. While some appeals are resolved within months, others may take a year or longer from filing to decision.

Common Questions About Florida Appeals

Many people assume that appeals involve re-arguing facts or presenting new evidence. In Florida, appellate courts generally do neither. The focus remains on legal error and whether the trial court correctly applied the law.

Another common question concerns the enforcement of judgments. Filing an appeal does not automatically stop enforcement of a trial court order. Separate procedures may apply depending on the circumstances.

If you have questions about the appellate process in Florida, you should contact an experienced lawyer who can explain your options clearly and thoroughly.

Appellate Practice Attorneys in St. Augustine, Florida

Vo Law brings over three decades of legal experience to St. Augustine, Florida, and the surrounding area. We offer personalized strategic planning for businesses of all sizes, alongside guidance and contract structuring for wills, trusts, and estates. In total, our attorneys have handled over $1 billion in real estate and commercial transactions.

We leverage technology to enhance efficiency and provide forward-thinking legal solutions. Our commitment to innovation and precision ensures effective, results-driven solutions.